Dear client,
Last week, together with my partner, Bruno Brum, I attended a hearing before the Labour Court in a case in which a dentist, hired as a self-employed professional, seeks recognition of an employment relationship and payment of salary and severance amounts totalling approximately R$ 800,000 against a dental clinic.
Two points deserve attention. First, the amount involved: a judgment of this magnitude could significantly compromise a clinic's financial stability. Second, the importance of choosing the right type of engagement for the professionals who provide services to companies.
The experience leads us to an important reflection: a hiring decision should not be defined solely by immediate cost, by the preference of the parties, or by the usual practice of a given sector. It must be examined in light of the activity performed and the way the relationship will actually be conducted.
With the tax reform, this analysis gains an additional dimension. Besides labour, social security, and contractual aspects, hiring legal entities requires attention to the effects of the new consumption taxation model, especially the incidence of the Tax on Goods and Services (IBS), the Contribution on Goods and Services (CBS), and the possibilities of using credits.
What is under discussion at the Supreme Court
The relevance of this analysis is evidenced by Theme 1,389 of general repercussion at the Supreme Federal Court (STF). The controversy involves three central issues: the lawfulness of hiring legal entities or self-employed workers to provide services; the jurisdiction to hear cases in which fraud in these contracts is alleged; and the definition of who must prove the alleged irregularity — the worker or the hiring company.
This is not a discussion restricted to one profession or economic segment. The debate reaches different forms of civil and commercial engagement, including healthcare professionals, lawyers, sales representatives, and technology professionals, among others.
For those who run a company, the message is clear: the hiring model deserves its own legal analysis, and not merely the replication of a solution used by other organisations. Planning is necessary.
The tax reform also enters the equation
Hiring a legal entity should not be evaluated solely by the amount indicated in its commercial proposal. Under the new system, the provider's tax regime and the treatment applicable to the transaction may influence the hiring party's use of IBS and CBS credits, subject to legal conditions. Therefore, comparing proposals will require understanding not only how much is paid, but also what the effective cost of the engagement is.
Simples Nacional illustrates this need for analysis well. The reform preserves the regime and allows opting companies to pay IBS and CBS under the regular regime, separately from the other taxes covered by Simples. This choice may change both the provider's appropriation of credits and the credits the transaction allows its client to use. Therefore, the information that a company "is in Simples" will not, by itself, be enough to understand all the tax effects of the engagement.
This does not mean that hiring a legal entity will always be more advantageous, nor that the reform will produce the same effect for all service providers. The assessment must consider the regime of both parties, the nature of the service, the legally admitted credits, and the impact on prices and margins.
The official guidance itself emphasises that the advantage of opting for the regular payment of IBS and CBS depends on each business's profile. The proposal, therefore, is to integrate the analyses: to study the legal adequacy of the relationship and, at the same time, to simulate its economic and tax effects. A possible tax advantage should not be treated as a sufficient answer for choosing the type of engagement.
Before hiring, you must understand the relationship
It is precisely at this moment that we propose preventive action. Before choosing between hiring an employee, a self-employed professional, or a legal entity providing services, we invite our clients to examine with us concrete questions:
- How will the work be organised and monitored?
- What will be the professional's degree of autonomy?
- Will personal performance of the services be required?
- How will schedules, availability, and compensation be defined?
- Will the contract clauses match the routine the parties intend to establish?
- What documents should record the engagement and its performance?
- What will be the effective cost of the chosen type of engagement, considering charges and tax effects?
- When hiring a legal entity, what is the provider's regime and what are its effects on the hiring company?
- How should contracts govern prices and any changes in tax burden during the transition?
Our proposal is that these questions be discussed before the relationship begins — and revisited when there are relevant changes in the way of working or in the economic assumptions of the engagement.
An invitation to review your engagements
Last week's experience reinforces the purpose of this editorial: to encourage our clients to learn about the types of engagement and to seek guidance in choosing the one that matches the company's needs and the real characteristics of the service provision.
We propose that this review not be limited to new contracts. Existing relationships should also be part of this conversation, especially when the routine departs from what was initially agreed or when prices need to be reassessed in light of the new tax scenario.
Our firm is available to study each situation, in dialogue with the company's accounting team, to clarify the alternatives, and to guide the structuring of engagements. The goal is not to offer a single formula, but to build legally grounded, economically aware decisions that are consistent with the reality of each business.
Ricardo Petereit
Founding Partner of Petereit Advogados Associados
16 November 2026


